Why Multitasking Doesn't Work (and What to Do Instead)
Multitasking feels productive and measurably isn't. Here's what task switching really costs your brain, and the single-task habits that actually work.
By Kurt Woleret

Last Tuesday I watched a guy on the L train answer email, scroll a feed, and listen to a podcast at the same time. He looked incredibly busy. He also read the same email three times, because I was shamelessly watching his screen. That's multitasking in one image: maximum motion, minimum progress.
I say this with love, as a person who once kept fourteen browser tabs open during a deadline week and called it a system. The research on multitasking is unusually blunt for psychology. It doesn't say multitasking is hard. It says that for focused work, it basically doesn't exist.
You're not multitasking. You're switching.
Here's the part that changed how I work. When you think you're doing two cognitive tasks at once, your brain is almost never running them in parallel. It's toggling between them, fast, like a bartender covering two registers. Every toggle has a cost: your brain has to shut down the rule set for task one, load the rule set for task two, and reorient. Psychologists call these switch costs.
The classic work here comes from Joshua Rubinstein, David Meyer and Jeffrey Evans, who had people alternate between tasks like math problems and classification tasks while measuring the time lost on every switch (Rubinstein et al., 2001, Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance). The losses showed up every single time, and they got bigger as the tasks got more complex. Each individual switch costs a fraction of a second. But if you're flipping between a spreadsheet and a group chat every ninety seconds for an afternoon, those fractions stack into real, lost hours.
And time is the cheap part. The expensive part is depth. Complex work needs your head to hold a lot of context at once, and every switch dumps some of that context on the floor. You come back to the document and spend two minutes remembering what you were even arguing.
The heavy multitasker paradox
Here's where it gets genuinely funny, in a bleak way. You'd think people who multitask constantly would at least be good at it. Practice makes perfect, right?
A Stanford team led by Eyal Ophir tested exactly that. They compared heavy media multitaskers with light ones on filtering, memory and task-switching tests (Ophir et al., 2009, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences). The heavy multitaskers did worse. Worse at ignoring irrelevant information, worse at organizing what they'd seen, and, the punchline, worse at switching between tasks. The thing they practiced most was the thing they were measurably bad at.
The people who multitask the most are the worst at it. Practice doesn't make perfect here. It makes distractible.
The likely reason: heavy multitaskers seem to develop a wider gate for incoming stuff. Everything gets in. That's useful if your job is noticing things, and terrible if your job is finishing things.
Why your brain keeps falling for it
If multitasking is so bad, why does it feel so good? Because switching delivers novelty, and your brain loves novelty like my radiator loves clanking at 3 a.m. Checking a new message gives you a tiny hit of something happening. Staying with a hard paragraph gives you nothing for minutes at a time. Of course the inbox wins.
There's also the busyness illusion. Juggling feels like effort, and we quietly grade ourselves on effort instead of output. A day of two hundred small switches feels productive the way a subway delay feels like travel. Lots of noise, not much distance.
What actually works
The fix isn't becoming a monk. I live in a one-bedroom apartment with thin walls and a phone; monk mode is not on the menu. The fix is making single-tasking slightly easier than switching, in blocks short enough that your brain doesn't revolt.
- Work in short, single-task sprints. Twenty to forty minutes on one thing, one tab, one document. When the urge to check something hits, write it on paper and keep going. The urge passes in about thirty seconds, which is shorter than the recovery from acting on it.
- Batch the small stuff. Messages, email and admin go in two or three scheduled piles a day instead of being a continuous drizzle over everything else.
- Put the phone somewhere that requires standing up. Friction beats willpower. It always has.
- Take a real reset between blocks. Not a feed. Switching from work to a feed isn't a break, it's just a different kind of switching.
That last one matters more than people think. The in-between moments decide whether your next block starts focused or scattered. I've started spending two or three minutes between sprints watching something slow instead: a kettle, the window, or a drifting texture in Feelsy with the sound low. It gives your eyes one unhurried thing to follow, which is the exact opposite of a feed, and the next work block starts noticeably cleaner. A couple of slow breaths with the 4-7-8 exercise does the same job if screens are the problem in the first place.
The honest summary
Multitasking survives on vibes. The data says switching between cognitive tasks costs time on every single toggle, that the costs grow with task complexity, and that chronic multitaskers test worse, not better, at the underlying skills. You don't need a productivity philosophy to act on that. You need one tab, a piece of paper for stray urges, and an actual pause between blocks.
Do one thing. Then do the other thing. It's the least glamorous advice I've ever written, and it works.
Feelsy is a wellness product, not medical advice. If stress, anxiety or sleep problems persist, please speak with a qualified professional.
References
- Rubinstein, J. S., Meyer, D. E., & Evans, J. E. (2001). Executive control of cognitive processes in task switching. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 27(4), 763–797.
- Ophir, E., Nass, C., & Wagner, A. D. (2009). Cognitive control in media multitaskers. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 106(37), 15583–15587.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is multitasking actually possible?
For tasks that need thought, no. Your brain doesn't run two cognitive tasks in parallel; it toggles between them, and every toggle has a switch cost while it unloads one task's rules and loads the other's. You can pair a truly automatic activity with a mental one, like walking while talking, but two tasks that both need attention just take turns.
How much time does task switching waste?
Research by Rubinstein, Meyer and Evans found measurable time lost on every single switch between tasks, with bigger losses as tasks got more complex. Each switch only costs a fraction of a second, but if you flip between work and messages every minute or two all afternoon, those fractions stack into real lost hours, plus the extra minutes spent rebuilding context each time.
Does practicing multitasking make you better at it?
The evidence points the other way. A Stanford study comparing heavy media multitaskers with light ones found the heavy group did worse at filtering out irrelevant information, worse at organizing what they'd seen, and worse at switching between tasks. The thing they practiced most was the thing they tested worst at.
What should I do instead of multitasking?
Work in single-task sprints of twenty to forty minutes with one tab and one document, write stray urges on paper instead of acting on them, batch messages and email into a few scheduled piles a day, and keep your phone somewhere that requires standing up. Between blocks, take a real reset by watching or doing something slow rather than opening a feed, which is just more switching.
Are breaks spent scrolling still breaks?
Not really. Switching from work to a feed trades one kind of rapid attention-switching for another, so your focus never gets the unhurried pause it needs. A better reset is two or three minutes of something genuinely slow, like looking out the window, watching a drifting texture, or a few rounds of slow breathing, so the next work block starts clean.

About the author
Contributing writer
Kurt is a New York based writer covering the practical science of stress, sleep and focus. He is the resident sceptic of the Journal: if a technique cannot survive a crowded subway commute and a deadline week, he is not interested in it.
Feel it for yourself.
Feelsy turns reading about calm into practising it. Two minutes of a slow texture is often the whole difference.
Related reading
Breath & BodyAttention Residue: The Hidden Tax of Task Switching
Every task switch leaves attention residue that quietly drains your focus. Here's the research, and how to actually clear your head between tasks.
Breath & BodyThe Pomodoro Technique: Why 25 Minutes Beats Willpower
The Pomodoro Technique breaks work into 25-minute sprints with real breaks. Why the tomato timer works, where it fails, and how to fit it to your brain.
Breath & BodyPopcorn Brain: Why Your Attention Keeps Popping to the Next Thing
Popcorn brain is what constant scrolling trains your attention to do: pop, jump, repeat. Here's the research on shrinking focus and how to retrain yours.
Breath & BodyThe Six Healing Sounds: A Gentle Guide to Liu Zi Jue
Liu Zi Jue, the Six Healing Sounds, is a qigong practice built on six slow exhalations. A beginner's guide to the sounds, their history, and how to start softly.
Breath & BodyWhat Is Brain Rot? A Skeptic's Guide to the Scroll
Brain rot was Oxford's 2024 word of the year, but is your brain actually rotting? Here's what endless low-effort content really does to attention.
Breath & BodyWhy Walking Helps You Think: The Science of the Thinking Walk
Why does walking help you think? Stanford research found walking roughly doubled creative output, even on a treadmill facing a wall. How to use it.